As the leaves start to turn and the air gets crisper, I find myself diving into my favorite fall tradition: refreshing my wardrobe with cozy, timeless pieces. But this year, I’m trying to be more intentional about my choices—seeking out styles that are not only chic but also sustainable. It’s been a journey balancing my love for fashion with my commitment to slow living, and I’ve realized that it doesn’t have to be about sacrificing quality or style. Whether you’re someone who loves to splurge on luxurious staples or you prefer affordable options, there’s always a way to shop mindfully. So, I’ve put together this Fall Fashion Face-Off to help you decide between high-end and budget-friendly essentials that fit your style, values, and budget.
01 | Wool Overcoat
I’m a sucker for a good coat, and when the temperature drops, a wool overcoat becomes my go-to piece.
- Expensive Option:
- Hudson Virgin Wool Blend Overcoat – At around $400, this piece is definitely an investment, but it’s one that will last. The tailored fit and premium wool blend make it a timeless staple that I know would be in my wardrobe for years.
- Why I’d Choose It: Sometimes, it’s worth investing in a coat that can elevate every fall outfit and endure the test of time. Plus, knowing it’s made with quality materials gives me peace of mind.
- Affordable Option:
- Plaid Wool Wrap Coat – I found this beauty for around $140 on Etsy. It’s cozy, it’s chic, and the plaid design is perfect for fall. I love the idea of supporting small businesses while getting something stylish and affordable.
- Why I’d Choose It: If you’re looking for something comfortable that doesn’t break the bank, this coat is a fantastic option for layering.
02 | Chunky Knit Sweater
A chunky knit sweater is my absolute fall must-have, and I love how it feels like wearing a cozy hug all day long.
- Expensive Option:
- Mentone Half Zip Sweater – This $150 merino wool sweater feels luxurious. I can see myself throwing it on for a brisk walk in the park or dressing it up for a casual coffee date.
- Why I’d Choose It: Merino wool is worth the splurge if you’re looking for warmth without bulk, and it has a softness that makes it feel extra special.
- Affordable Option:
- Everlane Cotton Half-Zip Sweater – At $130, this organic cotton sweater caught my eye. It’s sustainable and offers that chunky knit look I love, but at a slightly lower price point.
- Why I’d Choose It: It’s affordable, sustainable, and comfortable. What more could I want? This sweater makes me feel good about my purchase without sacrificing style.
03 | Leather Flat
When I’m not in boots, I’m in leather flats—especially during those in-between fall days when it’s not too cold but you still want to look polished.
- Expensive Option:
- Classic Leather D’Orsay Loafer – Priced at $170, these loafers are stylish and comfortable. I love how they can take me from the office to weekend brunch.
- Why I’d Choose It: A pair of high-quality flats can last forever, and these loafers feel like a timeless addition to any wardrobe.
- Affordable Option:
- Darcy Leather Flats in Chestnut – For $70, these TOMS flats offer style, comfort, and a feel-good factor with their charitable initiatives.
- Why I’d Choose It: If you’re on a budget, these flats are a great option for fall. Plus, knowing my purchase gives back makes them even more appealing.
04 | Fall Scarf
A scarf is one of my favorite accessories to elevate any fall look, especially when it’s warm and soft.
- Expensive Option:
- Charter Club Women’s 100% Cashmere Oversized Scarf – This $200 cashmere scarf is so soft and luxurious. It’s one of those pieces you could throw over any outfit to instantly look more put-together.
- Why I’d Choose It: Cashmere is a splurge, but it’s incredibly warm and cozy. I’d love to have this as a long-lasting, luxurious accessory in my fall wardrobe.
- Affordable Option:
- Thisbee Plaid Wool Scarf – At about $60, this wool scarf offers the warmth and classic plaid design I adore without the high price tag.
- Why I’d Choose It: It’s affordable, practical, and sustainable. This scarf is perfect for adding warmth and a pop of fall color to my outfits.
05 | Denim Jacket
A good denim jacket never goes out of style, and I’m always on the hunt for one that adds a bit of edge to my fall outfits.
- Expensive Option:
- We The Free Denim Barn Coat – This $170 coat has a vintage-inspired feel that I just love. The oversized fit is perfect for layering, and it has that lived-in, worn look that makes it a versatile piece.
- Why I’d Choose It: If you’re a denim lover like me, a high-quality jacket like this is worth the investment. It’s something I know I’d wear season after season.
- Affordable Option:
- Levi’s Belted Dolman Trucker Jacket – Priced at $110, this jacket is a modern take on the classic denim jacket, with a belted waist that adds a fresh silhouette.
- Why I’d Choose It: It’s stylish, functional, and perfect for layering over sweaters on chilly days.
06 | Sweater Dress
I’ve always been a fan of sweater dresses for fall—they’re comfortable, stylish, and can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion.
- Expensive Option:
- Tascha Long Sleeve Rib Cardigan Sweater Dress – This $280 dress is made from a cozy blend of natural fibers, and I can just imagine how warm and stylish it would be for both casual and dressy days.
- Why I’d Choose It: It’s the perfect blend of comfort and elegance, and I know it’s a piece I could wear throughout the season.
- Affordable Option:
- Quince Long Sleeve Button-Up Sweater Dress – For $60, this dress is an affordable alternative that offers the same warmth and style without the high price tag.
- Why I’d Choose It: It’s budget-friendly but still stylish and cozy—perfect for those days when I want to look pulled together without too much effort.
07 | Warm Fall Leggings
When fall hits, leggings become my go-to for warmth and comfort. Whether I’m out for a brisk walk or cozying up at home, the right pair makes all the difference.
- Expensive Option:
- Girlfriend Collective’s High-Rise Compressive Leggings – $90. These are my top pick when I want something that feels as good as it looks. Made from recycled materials, they fit like a dream and hold up after countless wears.
- Why I’d Choose It: I love that these leggings are eco-friendly and durable. They’re an investment, but I know they’ll last for seasons to come.
- Affordable Option:
- Uniqlo’s Heattech Leggings – $30. On days when I just need a quick, warm layer, these are a lifesaver. They’re lightweight but keep me surprisingly warm. Plus, they fit into my budget without sacrificing sustainability.
- Why I’d Choose It: These are perfect for everyday wear. They’re affordable, cozy, and great for layering under fall sweaters or coats.
08 | Trench Coat
A trench coat is one of those pieces that instantly elevates any outfit. Every fall, I look forward to bringing mine out—it’s such a timeless staple.
- Expensive Option:
- Sabbia Oversized Italian Twill Trench Coat – $350. I fell in love with this trench the moment I saw it. The luxurious fabric and oversized fit make it both elegant and practical. It’s the kind of piece I know I’ll treasure for years.
- Why I’d Choose It: If I’m going to splurge, it’s on something classic and versatile. This trench coat is perfect for layering and will never go out of style.
- Affordable Option:
- Mango’s Double-Breasted Trench Coat – $140. When I’m looking for something stylish without the splurge, Mango always comes through. This trench has the perfect fit and looks way more expensive than it is.
- Why I’d Choose It: I love that it combines quality with affordability. It’s chic and functional—exactly what I need for fall, especially on those drizzly days.
In the end, whether you splurge on high-quality staples or find affordable options, it’s all about finding pieces that align with your personal style and values. I love the idea of mixing and matching both splurge-worthy items and budget-friendly finds to create a wardrobe that’s both sustainable and chic. Which option speaks to you this fall? Let me know in the comments below, and let’s continue the conversation about making thoughtful, stylish choices!
